Results 1 to 14 of 14

Thread: Who would your top 12 be?

  1. #1
    Australian Goddess~ Gemma's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2007
    Gender
    Female
    Posts
    3,825

    Who would your top 12 be?

    This is a simple thread asking you, if you had a choice, who would your top 12 be from the final 40?

    if you want to post reasons, go ahead (I know Ethan and RnR will.)

    Mine would be:
    Pia Toscano (Obvious choice)
    Rachel Zevita
    Haley Reinhard (after seeing what she can do)
    Thia Megia
    Charity Vance (cos she came back, don't know where she placed though, she's my cheat. Didn't make top 40 I don't think xD)
    Janelle Arthur
    Hollie Cavanaugh
    Colton Dixon (ROBBED.)
    Robbie Rosen
    Deandre Brackenstock
    Paul Mcdonald
    Tim Halperin
      Spoiler:  

    Which I forgot when I started to sink...

  2. #2
    Pia
    Kendra
    Hollie
    Haley
    Naima
    Thia
    -
    Tim
    Robbie
    Brett
    Colton
    DeAndre
    Jacob

    K
    RANDOMIZER~
      Spoiler:  
    TOP 12
    safe: PIA|KENDRA|THIA|TIM|ROBBIE|BRETT|COLTON|DEANDRE|JA COB
    B3: Haley, Hollie, Naima
    B2: Haley, Naima
    12TH: HALEY - forgettable

    TOP 11
    safe: KENDRA|HOLLIE|NAIMA|THIA|TIM|BRETT|DEANDRA|JACOB
    B3: Robbie, Pia, Colton
    B2: Robbie, Colton
    11TH: ROBBIE- bad song choice

    TOP10
    safe: PIA|KENDRA|THIA|TIM|BRETT|DEANDRE|JACOB
    B3: Naima, Hollie, Colton
    B2: Naima, Hollie
    10TH- NAIMA - lolgurl

    TOP9
    safe: PIA|KENDRA|HOLLIE|TIM|BRETT|DEANDRE|JACOB
    B3: Thia, Jacob, Colton
    B2: Thia, Colton
    9TH- COLTON- continously underwelmed.

    TOP8
    safe: KENDRA|HOLLIE|TIM|DEANDRE|JACOB
    B3: Brett, Thia, Pia
    B2: Thia, Pia
    JUDGES SAVE USED ON PIA

    TOP8 PART2
    safe: PIA|KENDRA|HOLLIE|THIA|TIM
    B3: DeAndre, Brett, Jacob
    8TH- JACOB- bound to happen
    7TH- BRETT- good but not outstanding

    TOP6
    safe: PIA|KENDRA|HOLLIE
    B3: Thia, Tim, DeAndre
    B2: Thia, Tim
    6TH- THIA

    TOP5
    safe: KENDRA|DEANDRE
    B3: Hollie, Tim, Pia
    B2: Hollie, Tim
    5TH- HOLLIE


    TOP4
    Kendra
    Pia
    DeAndre
    Tim

    B3: Tim, Pia, Kendra
    B2: Tim, Kendra
    4TH- KENDRA :o

    TAHP 3.
    in top 2- Pia
    B2: Tim, DeAndre
    3RD- TIM

    DEANDRE WINS AMERICAN IDOL 10 ♥

  3. #3
    Moderator BottleItUp's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2010
    Gender
    Male
    Location
    New Orleans
    Posts
    14,270

    Achievements

    I can't remember anyone before the top 24 so...

    1. Pia Toscano
    2. Kendra Chantelle (ROBBED.)
    3. Haley Reinhart
    4. Thia Megia
    5. Naima Adedapo
    6. Lauren Alaina
    7. James Durbin
    8. Jacob Lusk
    9. Casey Abrams (as much as I hate him...)
    10. Colton Dixon (only top 40 cut I remember...)
    11. Stefano Langone (passable in the semis.)
    12. Scotty McCreery ( but I'll admit he deserves at least 12th)

  4. #4
    In order of elimination, with genders balanced equally.

    12. Scotty McCreery
    11. James Durbin
    10. Kenzie Palmer
    09. Lauren Alaina
    08. Jacob Lusk
    07. Thia Megia
    06. Haley Reinhart
    05. Robbie Rosen
    04. Colton Dixon
    03. Casey Abrams
    02. Kendra Chantelle
    Winner: Pia Toscano


  5. #5
    Although I feel the girls that were put through with Haley helped her get through... I would've chosen.

    1. Haley Reinhart
    2. Pia Toscano
    3. Kendra Chantelle
    4. Rachel Zevita
    5. Lauren Turner
    6. Lauren Alaina
    7. Thia Megia
    8. James Durbin
    9. Casey Abrams
    10. Stefano Langone
    11. Paul McDonald
    12. Jacob Lusk
    13. Scotty McCreery

  6. #6
    Pia Toscano
    Kendra Chantelle
    Thia Megia
    Rachel Zevita
    Lauren Turner
    Haley Reinhart

    Colton Dixon
    Robbie Rosen
    Casey Abrams
    Scotty McCreery
    Deandre Brackensick
    Paul McDonald

  7. #7
    That's okay... RnRModel1's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2009
    Gender
    Female
    Location
    North Carolina
    Posts
    5,688
    GIRLS:
    Pia Toscano-Duh! Best singer on the show in the past two seasons.
    Janelle Arthur-She was a really good singer, and marketable. I don't know why the judges sent her home over just that one group performance.
    Lauren Alaina-Annoying personality, but a great singer.
    Kendra Chantelle-I originally thought she was fodder, but that girl could sing.
    Thia Megia-She had a beautiful voice. It seems like all of her supporters just died out after she made the Top Twelve.
    Kenzi Palmer-We only got to hear her audition, so who knows how she did in Hollywood, but her voice was terrific. Some Carrie Underwood qualities in it.

    BOYS:
    Colton Dixon-The most current and marketable guy this season. He could've been right up there with Lifehouse. Stupid decision cutting him in the Top Forty.
    James Durbin-I wasn't a fan of him early on, but he has truly proven that he's a great singer.
    John Wayne Shultz-He was a much, much better country singer than Scotty is.
    Jacob Lusk-He isn't very current, but he has a great voice, albeit more suitable for gospel music.
    Robbie Rosen-I thought for sure that he would make the Top Twelve. He had a very smooth tone.
    Aaron Sanders-We only got to hear his Las Vegas performance, but it sounded great! He was so much better than Jordan Dorsey, and should have gotten his spot.

    My final two would've been Pia and Colton.


  8. #8
    My Everything Ethan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2009
    Gender
    Male
    Location
    AKL/LA
    Posts
    6,552

    Achievements

    GIRLS

    Pia Toscano - Because she's brilliant and a future Grammy winner, platinum selling artist, blockbuster actress & icon of the century.

    Lauren Alaina - Beautiful voice. You really lose touch of this quality about her through all the pimping. She is undeniably gifted.

    Kendra Chantelle - Absolutely brilliant vocals. Sweet, soulful tone. She's beautiful and nailed GOMM.

    Lauren Turner - Once again, this girl just had the vocal talent that deserved to be in the Top 13 this season so much. Watching her in Las Vegas just settles it for me. She's versatile too.

    Karen Rodriguez - So underrated. She deserved to go way, way furtherer than she did. In my opinion, her voice is extremely current and pretty powerful too.

    Rachel Zevita - I thought a lot about this last spot. I'd throw Rachel in because she's all the right kinds of unique and totally bombed unexpectedly because of song choice. Rachel is a performer.

    GUYS

    Casey Abrams - He's a total performer. I love his style, personality, voice, everything. I love how he can switch up styles too.

    Deandre Brackensick - Most robbed of the Top 40? Definitely. Watch his YouTube videos. You can't go pass his brilliant 10 seconds of singing airtime without loving him. His hair is funky, his voice is funky, and he's just refreshing to watch.

    Robbie Rosen - One of the best effortless tones ever. He deserved a wild card and a larger fan base. He can do modern and classic ballads.

    Jacob Lusk - Getting only his HW performances is just not enough. He has steam and I love watching him each week.

    Stefano Langone - Again, underrated. His voice is really tender and current. Sometimes, it gets over the top but I can't seem to dislike his performances, especially when he always chooses some of my favourite songs/artists.

    Colton Dixon - Refer to RnR's post.


    IDOL XIV: Sarina . Clark . Rayvon . Quentin . Adanna . Joey .


  9. #9
    My Everything Ethan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2009
    Gender
    Male
    Location
    AKL/LA
    Posts
    6,552

    Achievements

    DEANDRE WINS AMERICAN IDOL 10 ♥
    No, he'll do that next year TYVM.


    IDOL XIV: Sarina . Clark . Rayvon . Quentin . Adanna . Joey .


  10. #10
    If he was white, forgettable and semi-goodlooking then yes, he would

  11. #11
    My Everything Ethan's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2009
    Gender
    Male
    Location
    AKL/LA
    Posts
    6,552

    Achievements

    You don't want to go there with DeAndre.


    IDOL XIV: Sarina . Clark . Rayvon . Quentin . Adanna . Joey .


  12. #12
    1. Pia Toscano
    2. Thia Megia
    3. Scotty McCreery
    4. Casey Abrams
    5. Jacob Lusk
    6. Paul McDonald
    7. Deandre Brackensick
    8. Kendra Chantelle
    9. Robbie Rosen
    10. Lauren Alaina
    11. Brett Lowenstern
    12. Naima Adedapo
    13. Colton Dixon

    Eliminated in that order.

  13. #13
    Pia Toscano
    Kendra Chantelle
    Haley Reinhart
    Lauren Turner
    Lauren Alaina
    Thia Megia
    ^ didn't like most of the girls, so the last 2 were hard to choose

    Casey Abrams
    Colton Dixon
    Robbie Rosen
    Jacee Badeaux
    Tim Halperin
    Brett Loewenstern


  14. #14
    RTVG Apprentice
    Join Date
    Feb 2012
    Posts
    10
    Ok I. AM. THE. BIGGEST. NAIMA/THIA. FAN. EVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    From 13th to winner
    Chris Medina
    Karen Rodreguiez
    Brett Lowernstern
    Lauren Alaina
    Jacob Lusk
    Scotty Mc Creery
    Paul Mc Donald
    Pia Toscano
    Casey Abrams
    James Durbin
    Thia Megia/Naima Adedapo

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •