PDA

View Full Version : Girls You Like that Others Dislike (and vice-versa)



Chantal_Is_Love
10-13-2008, 11:52 AM
Mine are:

Mercedes (I noticed a lot of people didn't think she deserved F2)
Ann (On the show, I liked her...until they eliminated Norelle. :lol)
Bre (People didn't think she deserved F3, I think she could've won)
Kyle
Coryn
Melrose (not sure if people disliked her though)
Jaslene
Bianca
Whitney (I liked her until they went overseas)
Clark (:giggle :love)
Brittany

And the most obvious one


DOMINIQUE!!! :love :love :love :love

duckiies
10-13-2008, 12:04 PM
Like:

- Adrianne
- Camille (I kind of liked her)
- Eva
- Dominique
- Saleisha (I've grown to kind of like her...kind of)
- Samantha C11
- Elina
- Bianca

Dislike:

- Ann
- Kristi
- Ashley
- Samantha C8
- Fatima
- McKey

There are more, but I just don't feel like writing them down rtm.

Rikku
10-13-2008, 12:05 PM
I'll just do dislike

1. Natasha
2. Anya
3. McKey

n11r
10-13-2008, 12:15 PM
Dominique is love :love

hottfroggy77
10-13-2008, 05:14 PM
like that others dislike

whitney (c10)
bre
hannah
eva
elina
jaslene (she was disliked more when she first won)
joanie
lisa (c5)


dislike that others like

katarzyna
natasha
brittany (c4)
caridee
a.j.
jayla

omgwtfbbq
10-13-2008, 05:16 PM
I looooooved Hannah while everyone seemed to hate her. I never understood why, she was so cute and had the prettiest eyes.

Wiest
10-13-2008, 06:55 PM
Like that others dislike:

Catie
Hannah
Sarah C4
Sarah C5
Kathy
Jenascia
Lauren C10 (Most people seem to hate her now)
Eva
Michelle C4
Cassandra C5

Dislike that others like:

Leslie
Aimee
Lisa C9
Felicia
Marjorie
Atalya
Cassandra C8
Michelle C7
Brittany C4

rlykewl
10-13-2008, 07:01 PM
Liked:

1. Adrianne
2. Leah
3. Norelle
4. Lluvy
5. Michelle C4
6. Kim C5
7. Jade
8. Melrose
9. Victoria
10. Claire

Disliked:

1. Shandi to a certain extent.
2. MERCEDES BARF.
3. Yaya
4. Nik to a certain extent.
5. Jayla
6. Danielle
7. Chantal
8. Fatima, she was a bitch
9. Aimee
10. Sheena

nicole850
10-13-2008, 07:29 PM
Like:

Robin
Mercedes
Bre
Sarah C5
Melrose
Christian
Diana
Dominique
Whitney


Dislike:

Ann
Tatiana
Jayla
Caridee
Natasha
Analeigh

Ohmygosh
10-13-2008, 08:00 PM
Like
-Mercedes
-Camille
-Cassie
-Naima
-Bre
-Brooke C6
-Melrose
-Saleisha
-Allison
-Sheena

Dislike
-Yoanna
-Joanie
-Renee
-Nicole C5
-Brittany C8
-Aimee

I have more though

wts
10-13-2008, 08:03 PM
I cannot stand Yoanna and Katarzyna.

baka07414
10-14-2008, 05:48 AM
Is this like a revised version of "overrated/underrated thread"?:D
me likey:
Sara C6
Ambreal
Dom(not really a fan of them, but they are not that bad)
Nnenna
Brooke C6
Diana
Megg
Hannah

me dislikey:
Natasha(she doenst look like model and recently I found her personality toady)
Renee(total bxxxx)
Ann
Claire
Janet
Mercedes
Brooke C7
Sheen-ugh
Yaya
Clark

I think I have more though...

GuruBishisama
10-14-2008, 10:27 AM
SOME THAT I DISLIKE THAT EVERYONE ELSE LOVES~

-Katarzyna: It's not to say I dislike her, but I never found her as sensational as everyone else did. Preshow when the cycle ten girls were revealed, everyone was peeing their pants in anticipation for Katarzyna and I was trying soooo hard to see what was so extraordinarly beautiful about this girl and I just couldn't. I also think that while a lot of her post show shots have been impressive, I didn't think her work on the show was anything special. Though many of her pictures were pretty, not one of them was really that amazing to me. People loved the face in her Fuerzabruta but I think she totally forgot her body there, which knocked the power of the shot a lot. Er, anyway, I thought what they eliminated her for was fair blah blah blah, though I will say that when re-watching cycle ten, I finally am seeing why people found her so beautiful. It's a shame it didn't come through as much in photos.

McKey- Pretty much a repeat of the Katarzyna schpeel-- back when the cycle 11 Vogue ad was released, everyone was going crazy over girl number five, and I just couldn't see it. When the first episode premiered, I tried to like her, I really, really did, because I thought she had a great personality and a strong first photo, but I just can't see anything in her look that intrigues me. I will admit it is hard for me to judge her photos fairly because her look just does nothing for me at all. People call her fiercee shot stunning and I could pass over it and not look twice.

Cassie- I will admit that my view of cycle 3 was skewed because of how I watched it--I had read a blurb about the final four in EW magazine, and then a week later, VH1 was showing the whole season in preparation for the finale. I went online and was obviously able to figure out who went home when, so when watching the season, I was automatically inclined to root for the final three girls because I knew they would all make it far.

That being said, I thought Cassie was miserably boring looking. Her face just lacked any sort of intrigue for me--I have come to realize that I tend to like more "conventionally pretty" girls on ANTM but Cassie was conventionally dull in every way. Her own oblivious, definition changing denial of her eating disorder earned her no sympathy either.

LISA J- Um no.

HELLROSE- If I knew her in real life, I suspect I would have a really strong urge to punch her in the vagina.

ALICE BURDEU- "oh my! did I have another spontaneous abortion?"

That's my caption for every picture she's ever taken.

SOME GIRLS I LIKED WHO EVERYONE THINKS SHOULD BURN AND STUFF

JAEL- I have said this to hell and back but Jael was finger-waving fierce, and I hated her preshow. At least on FoRT, during cycle 8 preshow, everyone was labeling Jael as the next Mollie/AJ (which she was in a way), and I was like "UM BAAARF" but she really grew on me. I thought a lot of her pictures were quite pretty, but most of all, I was won over by her personality, which I thought always seemed genuine.

WHITNEY T- Yeah, sorry duck, but I was pulling for Whitney in the finale. I never liked Anya much (another one where I tried but just couldn't get into her look), and even though I will agree that Whitney didn't deserve the win over Anya (who absolutely outperformed her) I liked Whitney better the whole season :/

STACY ANN- Any love for Stacy Ann came post show, it seems. Not me. She was my preshow fave tbh.

DOMINIQUE/JANET/JOSLYN- Old girls, no potential, but if they can bring it I'm happy.

Nade
10-14-2008, 11:06 AM
Girls I love that everyone dislikes:

Whitney (cycle 8): This is probably the main one, as practically 99.9999999999999999999999% of Top Model fans disliked her, but I thought she was AMAZING. :smitten I thought she was absolutely stunning, if a little commercial, had a fantastic personality with great personality, charisma and charm, plus I loved how intelligant and eloquant she was. I also, honestly, loved all her pictures, apart from the Boy-Girl one but the concept sucked for that anyway. She would have made a perfect winner IMO.

Brooke (cycle 7): I know outside the board she's incredibly popular but here she is not liked at all. At first I thought "UGH! Typical valley girl, yawn!" but after her makeover, I was totally one team Brooke. It really brought out her features, and definately made her more edgy (I think it was one of the best makeovers in ANTM history) and since than I thought all her photos were great. Her "wobbly runway" shot will remain my favourite photo of cycle 7. I totally think Eugena should have left instead of her.

And the rest.

Anchal
Samantha (c11)
Ambreal
Nicole (I think she deserved to win, completely)
Cassie (IDK if she's popular or not tbh)
Jennipher (To an extent)

Girls I dislike who everyone else loves:

Claire: Will NEVER get the love for this girl. She was fug and her photos weren't anything special.
Jaslene: I just can't like her. EVER.
Clark: People were devestated when she was eliminated...I was over the moon.
Eugena: Sure, her post show career is great but on the show she sucked completely.

ANTopmodel
10-14-2008, 11:17 AM
SOME THAT I DISLIKE THAT EVERYONE ELSE LOVES~

McKey- Pretty much a repeat of the Katarzyna schpeel-- back when the cycle 11 Vogue ad was released, everyone was going crazy over girl number five, and I just couldn't see it. When the first episode premiered, I tried to like her, I really, really did, because I thought she had a great personality and a strong first photo, but I just can't see anything in her look that intrigues me. I will admit it is hard for me to judge her photos fairly because her look just does nothing for me at all. People call her fiercee shot stunning and I could pass over it and not look twice.

WHITNEY T- Yeah, sorry duck, but I was pulling for Whitney in the finale. I never liked Anya much (another one where I tried but just couldn't get into her look), and even though I will agree that Whitney didn't deserve the win over Anya (who absolutely outperformed her) I liked Whitney better the whole season :/



These are my thoughts exactly about these two. Especially the Anya part. I really tried to like her but just couldn't!

GuruBishisama
10-14-2008, 12:35 PM
Girls I love that everyone dislikes:

Whitney (cycle 8): This is probably the main one, as practically 99.9999999999999999999999% of Top Model fans disliked her, but I thought she was AMAZING. :smitten I thought she was absolutely stunning, if a little commercial, had a fantastic personality with great personality, charisma and charm, plus I loved how intelligant and eloquant she was. I also, honestly, loved all her pictures, apart from the Boy-Girl one but the concept sucked for that anyway. She would have made a perfect winner IMO.

Brooke (cycle 7): I know outside the board she's incredibly popular but here she is not liked at all. At first I thought "UGH! Typical valley girl, yawn!" but after her makeover, I was totally one team Brooke. It really brought out her features, and definately made her more edgy (I think it was one of the best makeovers in ANTM history) and since than I thought all her photos were great. Her "wobbly runway" shot will remain my favourite photo of cycle 7. I totally think Eugena should have left instead of her.

And the rest.

Anchal
Samantha (c11)
Ambreal
Nicole (I think she deserved to win, completely)
Cassie (IDK if she's popular or not tbh)
Jennipher (To an extent)

Girls I dislike who everyone else loves:

Claire: Will NEVER get the love for this girl. She was fug and her photos weren't anything special.
Jaslene: I just can't like her. EVER.
Clark: People were devestated when she was eliminated...I was over the moon.
Eugena: Sure, her post show career is great but on the show she sucked completely.

SOME THOUGHTS:

I didn't like Whitney's photos, but I agree that she had a lot of potential to be a super winner--especially in terms of giving Tyra the role model she wants. She is a curvy girl who is still beautiful and had the right proportions, a black girl who is intelligent and studies at an Ivy League school. And her personality was nice to boot. I think if she had gotten her act together on the shoots, she could have been phenomenal.

TWO- Brooke was awesome. IA about her makeover being magic--a lot of times, they give the "pretty blondes" dark hair (Kyle, Clark) but I don't think it always edges them out. Brooke took fabulous photos, and I think she was a prime example of a girl who was commercial but could take an editorial photo--If her hairstyle on the hair wars shoot was less cheesy, I think people would love that particular photo a lot more. And her wobbly runway is the best photo that week, easily.

THREE- Eugena blew on the show and I hate that people forget that. If Monique had done the wobbly runway shoot, Eugena would have been the third girl out.

duckiies
10-14-2008, 02:45 PM
TWO- Brooke was awesome. IA about her makeover being magic--a lot of times, they give the "pretty blondes" dark hair (Kyle, Clark) but I don't think it always edges them out. Brooke took fabulous photos, and I think she was a prime example of a girl who was commercial but could take an editorial photo--If her hairstyle on the hair wars shoot was less cheesy, I think people would love that particular photo a lot more. And her wobbly runway is the best photo that week, easily.

ITA, you have completely taken the words out of my mouth. I loved Brooke, and maybe she lacked in potential, but she took great photos and had a really beautiful face.

aju
10-15-2008, 05:07 AM
Girls I liked that others disliked:

- Julie (She was funny okay)
- Noelle (Ahahahaha)
- Jennipher (She could have beat Ann's ass quite easily)
- Stacy Ann (From Day 1)
- Jayla
- Naima (FOREVER)
- Sarah C5 (She was gorgeous IMO)
- Bre
- Renee (LOVE)

Girls I disliked that others liked:

- Claire (BARF)
- Shandi (BARFFFFF)
- Mercedes (BARF!!!)
- Kahlen (Seriously......)
- Samantha C11 (Bitch thinks she's sooo bubbly and cute and funny)
- Kim C5 (A lot of people loved her while the show was airing, she was so... UGLY)

mr.kuzmich
10-20-2008, 11:32 PM
Like that others dislike:

LAUREN c10

Dislike that others like:

WHITNEY
FATIMA

dongdongahdong
10-20-2008, 11:41 PM
Like that others dislike:
Sarah C5
Sara C6
Whitney C10
Naiman
Lauren C10
Jennipher C3
Domdom
Jas
Brooke C7

Dislike that others like:
Eva
Kahlen
Mercedes
Samantha C8
Ann
Anchal
Kat - I like her sometimes. I never saw anything mind blowing though.
Alice Burdeu

mr.kuzmich
10-20-2008, 11:44 PM
Like that others dislike:
Sarah C5
Sara C6
Whitney C10
Naiman
Lauren C10
Jennipher C3
Domdom
Jas
Brooke C7

Dislike that others like:
Eva
Kahlen
Mercedes
Samantha C8
Ann
Anchal
Alice Burdeu

How could I forget Kahlen! She's such a fan favorite and I happen to dislike her.

Tyler Neal
10-20-2008, 11:52 PM
Girls I liked that others dislike:

- Renee
- Kyle
- Michelle c4
- Brooke c6

Ohmygosh
10-21-2008, 12:08 AM
Like
-Mercedes
-Camille
-Cassie
-Naima
-Bre
-Brooke C6
-Melrose
-Saleisha
-Allison
-Sheena

Dislike
-Yoanna
-Joanie
-Renee
-Nicole C5
-Brittany C8
-Aimee

I have more though

I forgot to add Heather to my dislike list.

Sundae Morning
10-21-2008, 06:52 AM
Like
Ebony C1
Jenascia
Camille
Kelle
Cassie
Yaya
Jade
Melrose
Ebony c9
Claire
Clark

Dislike
Shannon
Mercedes
Ann
Amanda c3
Brooke c6
Megan
Caridee
Victoria
Amis
Marvita
Aimee
Katarzyna (during the show)
Elina
Samantha c11

Chantal_Is_Love
10-21-2008, 07:22 AM
Dislike

Elyse
Shandi
Yaya
Michelle (4)
Kahlen (something about her......)
Kim
Amanda & Michelle
Megg
Megan
Britt (8)
Victoria
Sarah (9)
Claire
Fatima
Nikeysha
McKey
Elina

nkaufie
09-23-2011, 11:25 AM
Dislike: Brittany C4, Joanie, Anya, Analeigh, Fo, Allison, Jane, Esther, Alexandria

Carcole
09-23-2011, 11:29 AM
Dislike
Elina (C11)
Fo (C12)
Alexandra (C14)
Nicole (C16)

71000
09-24-2011, 02:02 AM
Like that others dislike:
Shannon C1
Adrianne C1
Mercedes C2
Julie C3
Lisa C5
Sara C6
Brooke C7
Claire C10
Laura C13
Jessica C14

Dislike that others like:
Elyse C1
Yoanna C2
Shandi C2
Nik C5
Joanie C6
Eugena C7
Lauren C10
Marjorie C11
Elina C11

Shiru_chan88
09-24-2011, 02:26 AM
Like that others dislike:
Bre C5
Renee C8
Isis C11
Alexandra C14
Dominique C16
Kasia C16

Dislike that others like:
Kahlen C4
Melrose C7
Elina C11
Hannah C11 (at least I feel like there's some love from RTVG that I don't get at all)
Erin C13
Angelea C14
Gabrielle C14
Anamaria C15

Shiru_chan88
09-24-2011, 07:21 PM
Also add to Like that Others Dislike list: Sam C11

ANTMmaker
09-24-2011, 08:22 PM
^ I liked her.
Girls I like that others Disliked:
Jessica (Cycle 12) :love
Tahlia (Cycle 12)
Elina (Cycle 11) - Fiercest ANTM girl in my opinion.

engsamnang
09-24-2011, 11:04 PM
I'm seem to be just a new member here (i'm started at 2011). So, there is a lot of thing i don't know in rtvgames forum. I kinda see elina in both "like that other dislike" and "dislike that other like"..just doubt. So for rtvg people, what's elina actually belong to? Fan's favorite here or not?

Carcole
09-24-2011, 11:06 PM
^ i think elina is more of a fan favorite. i never got the love for her though

AZAM85
09-24-2011, 11:09 PM
Girls i didnt like but others did:

Shannon .. Commercial
Mercedes .. Commercial
Camille .. Bit*h
Yaya .. Also an overconfident Bit*h
Ann from C3 .. BLAH
Keenyah .. So full of herself
Bre .. she is not a hf model
Jayla .. pff nothing modelesque about this girl
Jade .. Shes a Bitch
Brooke.. She overstayed
Melrose.. Granma Mellisa :lol
Brittany c8 .. Whinning Bitch
Bianca .. Also a Bitch
Anya.. shes pretty but DUMB
Katrazanya .. I dont like her personality
Sam, Clark .. nothing special about them



Girls that I liked but others didnt:

Robyn .. if you dont think about her age for one second, she was actually beautiful
Eva .. Girl aint no Diva or a Bi*ch, She is a star
Norelle, Nicole from c3 .. Both Awsome
Kahlen and Cristina .. ROBBED
Lisa .. Girl had an amazing portfolio and was sabotaged
Jade .. Bitch but I like her :lol
Leslie.. she deserved to go overseas
AJ.. hf model
Dionne .. Love her
Janet .. She was unique
Claire .. hf Sabotaged
Marjorie, Sheena.. Both Sabotaged



Rest later.. My brain frooze up... :lol

AZAM85
09-24-2011, 11:10 PM
Girls i didnt like but others did:

Shannon .. Commercial
Mercedes .. Commercial
Camille .. Bit*h
Yaya .. Also an overconfident Bit*h
Ann from C3 .. BLAH
Keenyah .. So full of herself
Bre .. she is not a hf model
Jayla .. pff nothing modelesque about this girl
Jade .. Shes a Bitch
Brooke.. She overstayed
Melrose.. Granma Mellisa :lol
Brittany c8 .. Whinning Bitch
Bianca .. Also a Bitch
Anya.. shes pretty but DUMB
Katrazanya .. I dont like her personality
Sam, Clark .. nothing special about them



Girls that I liked but others didnt:

Robyn .. if you dont think about her age for one second, she was actually beautiful
Eva .. Girl aint no Diva or a Bi*ch, She is a star
Norelle, Nicole from c3 .. Both Awsome
Kahlen and Cristina .. ROBBED
Lisa .. Girl had an amazing portfolio and was sabotaged
Jade .. Bitch but I like her :lol
Leslie.. she deserved to go overseas
AJ.. hf model
Dionne .. Love her
Janet .. She was unique
Claire .. hf Sabotaged
Marjorie, Sheena.. Both Sabotaged



Rest later.. My brain frooze up... :lol

Mr.NickiMinaj
09-24-2011, 11:34 PM
I know one girl that i LOVED that everybody hated her. Whitney (C10) I loved that she won :smitten

BrittaniKline
09-25-2011, 12:00 AM
Analeigh Tipton:puke

nkaufie
09-25-2011, 02:09 AM
I know one girl that i LOVED that everybody hated her. Whitney (C10) I loved that she won :smittenI loved Whitney too, her portfolio was gorgeous. :smitten

Brittolly
09-25-2011, 03:58 AM
Like that others dislike:
SAMANTHA
BIANCA C9
KASIA
Dislike that others like:
HEATHER
BRITTANY C8
KAYLA
ANAMARIA

boreddork
09-25-2011, 05:43 AM
Like that others dislike:
Lauren C10
Alasia C14
Chelsey C15
Anamaria C15

Dislike that others like:
Jessica C14
Ann C15 (as a model)
Hannah C16
Brittani C16
Jaclyn C16
Nicole C16

Adele128
09-25-2011, 08:14 AM
I Like Them, But Dislike How The Others Are Overrating Them:
1. Jane Randall - RTVG Award for Overrated Girl Ever by RTVG
2. Nicole Lucas
3. Katarzyna Dollinska
4. Fatima Siad
5. Anya Kop (I love all three of Kat, Fatima and Anya, but I dislike them more and more after seeing how overrated they were here)
6. Nicole Linkletter (yeah bitch, Nik owned C5)

I Love Them, But The Others Seems to Can't See Anything Positive About Them:
1. Whitney Thompson - RTG Award for Underrated Girl Ever by RTVG
2. Kasia Pilewicz
3. Nik Pace
4. Dominique Reighard
5. Hannah White

I Hate Them, And The Others Seems to Hate Them as Well:
1. Tahlia Brookins - Worst contestant ever
2. Samantha Potter
3. Kelle Jacobs (I don't hate Kelle, she's sweet, but her photos are horrible. I still think it was a set-up, though)
4. Whitelle Cunningham
5. Keenyah Hill